THE HAGUE, May 17 (Hina) - The Hague war crimes tribunal has not ensured a fair trial for a former political leader of Croats in central Bosnia, Dario Kordic, as the unclear indictment against him and his unequal treatment during
proceedings brought about a confusing verdict for crimes that were not proved beyond reasonable doubt, said Stephen Sayers at the beginning of an appeals hearing in the case of Dario Kordic and Mario Cerkez before the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) on Monday.
THE HAGUE, May 17 (Hina) - The Hague war crimes tribunal has not
ensured a fair trial for a former political leader of Croats in
central Bosnia, Dario Kordic, as the unclear indictment against him
and his unequal treatment during proceedings brought about a confusing
verdict for crimes that were not proved beyond reasonable doubt, said
Stephen Sayers at the beginning of an appeals hearing in the case of
Dario Kordic and Mario Cerkez before the International Criminal
Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) on Monday.#L#
Kordic's US lawyer described the indictment as bad, incomplete and
equivocal, and claimed that prosecutors were modelling the case during
the trial depending on the presentation of evidence.
He also accused the prosecutors of intentionally covering up some
exculpatory evidence although they were supposed to show it to the
defence, too.
In this context, Sayers said that the prosecutors kept secret the
summary of the testimonies of another ICTY indictee, Tihomir Blaskic,
which he had given at hearings behind closed doors when he said that
Kordic had not been in the Bosnian Croat Defence Council (HVO) chain
of command, that he had not been his superior and that his statements
were not binding.
After the trial which lasted 240 days, the ICTY trial chamber in
Febraury 2001 sentenced Kordic to 25 years in prison and Cerkez, who
commanded HVO units in central Bosnia, to 15 years in prison. They
were charged with crimes against humanity and violations of laws and
customs of war committed during a campaign of persecution of Bosnian
Muslims in the Lasva River Valley during the Croat-Muslim conflict in
1992 and 1993. The gravest crime was the massacre of over 100 Muslims
(Bosniaks) in the village of Ahmici on 16 April 1993.
Both the defence and persecutors appealed against the verdict of the
trial chamber.
During the three-day appeals hearing which began on Monday before the
appeals chamber led by Judge Fausto Pocar, all sides will present
their arguments.
The prosecutors insisted on a life sentence for Kordic, and appealed
against the decision of the trial chamber to acquit Cerkez of the
Ahmici crime.
On Monday, Kordic's lawyers -- Stephen Sayers, Turner Smith and Mitko
Naumovski -- presented their arguments. Cerkez's lawyers -- Bozidar
Kovacic and Goran Mikulicic -- will present theirs on Tuesday and the
prosecutors, led by Norman Farrell, will do the same on Wednesday. The
appeals chamber will make a decision on the matter later on.
The verdict is based on hearsay and indirect evidence. The main
prosecution witness, known as AT and convicted of murder, admitted
that he had lied about his role in Ahmici at the trial, the lawyer
Sayers said.
The prosecutors must prove beyond reasonable doubt every element of
the criminal act or acquittal is ruled. The prosecutors in the Kordic
case failed to do so, despite a five-year investigation, assistance
offered by the Federation of Bosnia-Herzegovina and four trials on the
same crimes previously concluded, Sayers said alluding to the trials
of Blaskic, Delalic, Furundzija and Kupreskic.
In the courtroom the US lawyer showed copies of two orders for the
attack on the village of Ahmici signed by Blaskic, but the signatures
were different, from which the lawyer concluded that pieces of key
evidence were forged military documents.
He stressed that although he was the president of the Croatian
Democratic Union of Bosnia-Herzegovina (HDZ BiH), Kordic did not
mastermind the campaign of persecution and that he had no role in the
HVO chain of command.
Kordic and Cerkez have been in custody since 6 October 1997 when they
voluntarily surrendered to the UN court. They pleaded not guilty at
their initial appearance.
(Hina) ms