( Editorial: --> 0795 )
ZAGREB, May 1 (Hina) - "Titanic", a movie lauded across the globe
and bestowed with many awards, which tells the story of mythical
proportion about the sinking of the world's most exclusive ship,
has offended an experienced Croatian sea captain and marine writer,
Bruno Profaca.
Errors made by director James Cameron are serious: with an inexpert
and candied presentation of a seaman's life, he "brings into
question one of the greatest maritime tragedies of all time", and he
"approaches the honourable vocation of a seaman with
incomprehensible malice," Profaca criticises.
Captain Profaca, currently residing in Zagreb, especially takes
offence at the "ignoring and reversing of the strict hierarchy
aboard ship" in the movie.
"Maritime sailing is not only mere pot-boiling of those who live on
the sea and from the sea, but is a particular way of life, to which
(...)all the inhabitants of the coastal area, commonly referred to
as 'gente di mare', willingly incline. I believe that all those who
have really experienced the true way of life of a mariner (...),
having seen the showing of the seemingly magnificent cloned
"Titanic", left the movie theatre a bit depressed," Profaca wrote,
extensively analysing the movie in Sunday 26 April's edition of the
"Novi List" daily.
"If it had happened like that in reality - the "Titanic's" command
would have rightfully demanded protection from its union," Captain
Profaca said defending the dignity of his profession, and
condemning the movie's much too accentuated role of the ship's
constructor, as well as the non-existence of expert consultants
among sea captains to the movie's director.
He is especially perturbed by the character of "the unfortunate
captain Edward J. Smith", who was reduced to a "mute plastic figure
as if taken from some model of a ship in a museum," presented as
"almost having no purpose on the captain's bridge, and then as an
accessory singer in a church choir"...
And, "when the movie reached its worst moment, in the agony of the
collision, a call is heard 'starboard' (meaning turn the rudder to
the right), and the steersman feverishly begins turning the rudder
to the left!"
This "most lauded and most profitable movie in the world" is far
from, for example, "the magnificent English film 'Cruel Sea', which
was at the time "commended even by the British Royal Navy," Captain
Bruno Profaca wrote.
(hina) lm
011528 MET may 98
Španjolski kup: Real u četvrfinalu, Modrić igrao
Najava događaja - svijet - za petak, 17. siječnja
Najava događaja - Hrvatska - za petak, 17. siječnja
Najava događaja - kultura - za petak, 17. siječnja
Najava događaja - fotografije - za petak, 17. siječnja
Najava događaja - sport - za petak, 17. siječnja
Najava - gospodarstvo - za petak, 17. siječnja
Split: Uhićeni student predan pritvorskom nadzorniku
Anušić: Dostigli smo dva posto BDP-a izdvajanja za obranu
Engleska: Manchester United - Southampton 3-1